Two researchers have provided the first video-based observation of swimming and diving apes. Instead of the usual dog-paddle stroke used by most terrestrial mammals, these animals use a kind of breaststroke. The swimming strokes peculiar to humans and apes might be the result of an earlier adaptation to an arboreal life.
For many years, zoos have used water moats to confine chimpanzees, gorillas and orangutans. When apes ventured into deep water, they often drowned. Some argued that this indicated a definitive difference between humans and apes: people enjoy the water and are able to learn to swim, while apes prefer to stay on dry land.
But it turns out that this distinction is not absolute. Renato Bender, who is working on a PhD in human evolution at the School of Anatomical Sciences at the University of the Witwatersrand (Wits University), and Nicole Bender, who works as an evolutionary physician and epidemiologist at the Institute of Social and Preventive Medicine at the University of Bern, have studied a chimpanzee and an orangutan in the US. These primates were raised and cared for by humans and have learnt to swim and to dive. Their findings have been published online on 30 July in The American Journal of Physical Anthropology.
Perhaps this ability to learn to like water and learn to swim, requires zoos to reconsider the common approach to confine these Great Apes in outdoor enclosures by water-filled moats. Although, until now gorillas in zoos broke out of their enclosure by jumping the surrounding – apparently too small – water-filled moats, but swimming across the moat to escape has not been documented yet. With his escape in 2007, Bokito the male gorilla in Rotterdam Zoo, became big news. He jumped the water-filled moat around the rather new outdoor enclosure and injured a woman so bad she had to be hospitalised for weeks. Immediately after the incident the outdoor gorilla enclosure was closed for refurbishment and a wall appeared where the moat used to be.
Watch a compilation of the events that took place as a result of Bokito’s escape:
Renato Bender, lead author, School of Anatomical Sciences, Wits University, South Africa »
To prevent the chimp from drowning, the researchers stretched two ropes over the deepest part of the pool. Cooper became immediately interested in the ropes and, after a few minutes, he started diving into the two-meter-deep water to pick up objects on the bottom of the pool. ‘It was very surprising behaviour for an animal that is thought to be very afraid of water,’ said Renato Bender. Some weeks later, Cooper began to swim on the surface of the water.
The orangutan Suryia, who was filmed in a private zoo in South Carolina, also possesses this rare swimming and diving ability. Suryia can swim freely up to twelve meters.
Watch Cooper the chimp repeatedly made full submersions in deep water holding on to one or two ropes, often trying to grasp with one foot or one hand objects placed 2 m deep on the floor of the pool. He also is covering his eyes during the dives. He does that every time he submerges, which can be seen in the other videos where he goes under:
Suryia the orangutan swims with his limbs alternately forwards and backwards. Like Cooper, these movements are highly divergent from swimming movements known from other primates:
Both animals use a leg movement similar to the human breaststroke ‘frog kick’. While Cooper moves the hind legs synchronous, Suryia moves them alternatively. The researchers believe that this swimming style might be due to an ancient adaptation to an arboreal life. Most mammals use the so-called dog-paddle, a mode of locomotion that they employ instinctively. Humans and apes, on the other hand, must learn to swim. The tree-dwelling ancestors of apes had less opportunity to move on the ground. They thus developed alternative strategies to cross small rivers, wading in an upright position or using natural bridges. They lost the instinct to swim. Humans, who are closely related to the apes, also do not swim instinctively. But unlike apes, humans are attracted to water and can learn to swim and to dive.
‘The behaviour of the great apes in water has been largely neglected in anthropology. That’s one of the reasons why swimming in apes was never before scientifically described, although these animals have otherwise been studied very thoroughly. We did find other well-documented cases of swimming and diving apes, but Cooper and Suryia are the only ones we were able to film. We still do not know when the ancestors of humans began to swim and dive regularly,’ said Nicole Bender. ‘This issue is becoming more and more the focus of research. There is still much to explore,’ said Renato Bender.
Cooper could not wade on all fours in the shallow part of the pool. Watch how relaxed he is while adopting an upright position to keep his head above the water:
(Source: Wits University media release, 14.08.2013)